Jimmy Rollins or Andre Eithier?

Should I give up Jimmy Rollins for Andre Eithier? I lack power and stolen bases, but I just picked up Nyjer Morgan for SB. Eithier would be an upgrade on power, but I don’t know where he bats in the line up, plus he won’t have Manny in the line up with him now. I thought maybe I could pull of a double switch- Rollins and either Adam Lind or Ricky Weeks for Andre Either and either Alexei Ramirez (SS, 2nd and OF eligibility) or Stephen Drew. I kind of ran into a problem of having multiple players from the same team, so the rain cancellations killed me (Rolins/Victorino, Rios/Lind, Youkalis/Ortiz). Which way would you go? He has offered me a couple of trade offers for Rollins so far, so he is interested.